My favorite potato salad recipe is filled with eggs, sweet pickles, and slaw dressing that gives it a unique twist. I’ve been making it for years & it’s always a hit!
Click HERE to save recipe to Pinterest
I love this potato salad. I make it for almost all of our BBQs and every Easter.
A variation of this recipe was given to me years ago by my friend’s mom. I’m not a big fan of mayo so I liked that her recipe used mostly slaw dressing. I ran with it and made it my own.
I also typically don’t like crunchy things in my otherwise soft food (i.e. celery and pickles), but I let it slide in this dish.
- Potatoes – I like to use russet potatoes in my potato salad.
- Celery – I opt for celery hearts.
- Pickles – Sweet gherkins. I always get the “petite” size.
- Eggs – Hard boiled eggs.
- Slaw Dressing – I always use Marzetti slaw dressing.
- Mayo – I always use olive oil mayo.
- Salt & Pepper
HOW LONG DO I BOIL THE POTATOES?
First, start by scrubbing your potatoes then cutting into 1/2″ to 1″ pieces. Keep them similar in size so they’ll cook evenly. Add them to a large pot of salted water and bring to a boil over medium high heat. Cook them for 15-20 minutes or until fork tender. You don’t want them crisp but you also don’t want them too soft or you’ll end up with mashed potatoes.
Now that I have an instant pot, I’ve been using that to pressure cook my potatoes for potato salad. It’s slightly faster and less hands-on.
If you’re going that route, pour in a cup of water, add the potatoes to a steamer basket and place in the pot, cook on high pressure for 3 minutes. The pot will take about 10 minutes to come up to pressure, 3 minutes to cook, then quick release to finish.
PERFECT HARD BOILED EGGS
I’ve also started making my hard boiled eggs in the instant pot. It is fast and I find that they’re easier to peel!
You’ll add a cup of water to the instant pot, put the rack in, add the eggs, seal the pot, cook for 6 minutes on high, let stand for 6 minutes, then quick release and move the eggs to an ice bath for 6 minutes.
That’s it! They peel really easily and you can make a large batch.
If you want to boil them, I have a trick for that, too.
Add your eggs to a pot of salted water. Bring up to a boil then turn off heat and cover with a lid. Remove from the heat and let stand for 10 minutes in the water. After 10 minutes, drain and spray the eggs with cold water. You’ll have perfectly yellow yolks – no green!
TIPS & TRICKS
- I like to use russet potatoes. I’ve tried it with yukon gold and red skins, but always come back to russets.
- You’ll want your potatoes to be fork tender, but not too soft, or you’ll end up with mashed potato salad.
- The slaw dressing is what gives this potato salad great flavor. I always opt for Marzetti brand.
NEED MORE SIDE DISHES IN YOUR LIFE? TRY THESE:
TOOLS FOUND ON AMAZON TO HELP YOU:
- Potato peeler – I really like this one because it has a large handle that doesn’t slip out of your hands.
- Marzetti SLAW dressing – this is what makes this potato salad different & in my opinion, so good.
- Instant Pot – I am still new to the instant pot, but it does make boiling potatoes & eggs SUPER fast.
- Veggie Chopper – For a shortcut, you can use a veggie chopper for the pickles, celery, and even the eggs.
CONNECT WITH PERSNICKETY PLATES!
Follow along on my social media so you never miss a post!
Also, sign up to receive an email in your inbox for each new recipe:
HOW TO MAKE POTATO SALAD
My Favorite Potato Salad
- 9 medium russet potatoes cut into 1/2"-1" cubes
- 2 celery heart stalks diced
- 20 sweet petite gherkins or 10 regular size, diced
- 5 hard boiled eggs peeled & sliced
- 3/4 cup slaw dressing I use Marzetti
- 1/4 cup mayo
- salt and pepper to taste
- Scrub your potatoes, peel them and chop them into approximately 1/2″ – 1″ cubes. Keep the pieces similar in size so they will cook at the same speed.
- Add potatoes to a large pot of salted water and bring to a boil. Continue boiling until potatoes are fork tender. You don’t want them hard, but you also don’t want them too soft. Otherwise they’ll fall apart and you’ll have mashed potato salad.
- In another pot, boil your eggs.
- My egg boiling trick (that I think came from Rachael Ray) – Add your eggs to a pot of salted water. Bring up to a boil then turn off heat and cover with a lid. Remove from the heat and let stand for 10 minutes in the water. After 10 minutes, drain and spray the eggs with cold water. You’ll have perfectly yellow yolks – no green!
- While the potatoes are boiling, chop up the celery. I like the celery to be really small. Size is really up to you.
- Also, chop up the pickles and use an egg slicer to slice up the cooled eggs.
- Combine the egg, pickles and celery into a large bowl and season with salt and pepper, to taste.
- Once potatoes have finished cooking, I drain them and stick them into the fridge so they’re easier to work with. If they’re too hot, they’ll fall apart while you’re combining the ingredients.
- Once cooled, add the potatoes to the egg/pickle/celery mixture and season with more salt and pepper.
- Add the slaw dressing and mayo and stir to fully combine making sure all the potatoes are coated and the egg/pickle/celery is pretty evenly distributed. Add more salt and pepper and/or mayo or slaw dressing, to taste.
- Let it hang out in the fridge for a little while then serve.
Originally published April 8, 2013