You ever feel like you’re being watched? 👀 This spooky Spaghetti and Meatballs “Eyeball” Pasta is perfectly creepy for Halloween dinner. Cheese stuffed meatballs with olives turn into eyeballs on top of a bed of noodles.
Click HERE to save recipe to Pinterest
It’s almost Halloween, and that means it is time for pumpkin carving, apple picking, and spooky spaghetti with eyeballs! It’s a holiday that is celebrated with ghosts, goblins, and witches galore. And what better way to celebrate than with food? If you’re looking for a savory Halloween recipe this year, then look no further!
This eyeball pasta recipe takes an ordinary meatball and turns it into a dish that literally watches you while you eat! It is easy to make using sliced string cheese for the whites of the eye and black olives for an eerie black iris eyeball – perfect for any child or adult who wants a shocking dinner this holiday season. If you want to have some fun this Halloween season while still enjoying delicious food, then give this recipe a try!
INGREDIENTS & EQUIPMENT
Below is a list of ingredients with some helpful tips and suggestions for substitutions. Scroll all the way down for the full, printable recipe card with amounts & instructions.
Ingredients for the Pasta Base
NOODLES – One pound spaghetti noodles. You could also use zoodles.
PASTA SAUCE – One 24 ounce jar of your favorite pasta sauce or make it yourself.
Meatball “Eyeball” Ingredients
GROUND BEEF – I like to use ground sirloin because of the low fat content & the flavor, but use your favorite. Ground turkey or ground chicken can also be used in place of beef.
BREAD CRUMBS – You’ll be seasoning plain breadcrumbs. Alternatively, you can buy Italian breadcrumbs that would already be seasoned.
SEASONINGS – Garlic salt and Italian seasoning to season the meatballs.
PARMESAN CHEESE – Grated parmesan cheese.
STRING CHEESE– String cheese is mozzarella cheese. You’ll need four sticks, sliced into 4 pieces (16 total).
BLACK OLIVES – You can buy pre-sliced black olives or slice them yourself.
TOOLS FOUND ON AMAZON TO HELP YOU
You’ll need to use a large pot to boil your spaghetti and mix in your sauce for this recipe. You will need a large mixing bowl, a baking dish or sheet, a cutting board, and a knife for the eyeball meatballs. All in all, cleanup is easy with this recipe, especially if you clean as you go! By the end, you’ll only be left with one pot!
HOW TO MAKE SPOOKY EYEBALL PASTA
Make the Eyeball Meatballs
STEP ONE: In a large bowl, mix together the ground beef, breadcrumbs, garlic salt, Italian seasoning. Shape the meat into 16 (2″) meatballs. Place them into a baking dish.
STEP TWO: Slice the string cheese into 4 pieces and place one into each meatball, leaving the end sticking out. Top each with an olive slice.
STEP THREE: Bake at 375 degrees for 20 minutes or until meatballs are done (160 degrees internal temp).
Prepare the Pasta
STEP FOUR: While the meatballs are baking, cook your spaghetti noodles in salted water. Drain, return to pan, then top with your favorite jarred sauce. Stir to distrubute.
Combining the Pasta with the Eyeballs
STEP FIVE: Once the pasta and meatballs are done, create a “nest” of pasta on your plate and top with the eyeball meatballs!
WHAT TO SERVE WITH YOUR SPAGHETTI AND EYEBALLS
To complete your spooky meal, go for some roasted witch’s fingers (aka green beans) and mummified garlic bread! To make the garlic bread use a french loaf, cut in half length-wise and then again in the middle. Then you’ll want to take a cheese stick and cut long strips. If you have a mandolin, you can use it.
Lay the cheese slices on the bread haphazardly, mimicking a wrapped mummy. Finish it off with two thin slices of cheese stick whites for the eyes and top with sliced olives.
Of if you want some heat, try some Mummy Jalapeno Poppers!
Don’t forget dessert, for what is Halloween without sweets! My Halloween Tunnel Cake will have your family oohing and awing. The orange cheesecake center makes for a decadent dessert full of surprises! If you’re short on time, my Halloween Swirl Cream Cheese Brownies take right at 15 minutes to throw together and are sooo worth it!
Savory Halloween Spaghetti and Eyeballs FAQs
Can I use ground chicken or turkey instead of beef for the eyeballs?
Yes! You can use either ground chicken or turkey as a beef substitute, whichever your family prefers.
Can I use store-bought meatballs instead of making them from scratch?
Yes, but keep in mind that frozen store-bought meatballs are precooked. You will not be able to insert the string cheese without letting them thaw and removing some of the meat. Basically, they’ll be more work. Some stores offer pre-seasoned meatballs that have not been cooked yet in the meat department. Those would work better.
What if I don’t have string cheese?
If you don’t have string cheese on hand, you can use sliced cheese. You’ll want to lay the cheese on a cutting board and take a knife (a melon baller or measuring spoon would work well for this), and trace out a circle for each eye.
What if I don’t like olives? Can I use something else?
I have been trying to think of something you can use instead of olives, but I can’t come up with anything that is going to look the same. If you don’t like olives, you can always pick them off or make some for yourself (or the person who doesn’t like them) without the olives and have it be a blind eyeball!
HOW TO STORE IT
Store leftovers covered in the fridge for up to 4 days. Reheat in the microwave.
CAN YOU FREEZE IT
The meatballs will freeze well. Put them in an airtight freezer container for up to 3 months.
NEED MORE SAVORY HALLOWEEN RECIPES? TRY THESE:
DON’T FORGET THE HALLOWEEN DESSERTS:
Click here for my entire collection of Halloween recipes.
CONNECT WITH PERSNICKETY PLATES!
Follow along on my social media so you never miss a post!
Also, sign up to receive an email in your inbox for each new recipe:
It is VERY HELPFUL to me and other readers if you leave a review after you make my recipe. Please come back & let me know how it turned out!
Check out my flavor rich recipe books here!