Creamy macaroni and cheese made on the stovetop is so much better than anything from a box! This homemade shells and cheese recipe will become your family’s favorite mac and cheese!
Creamy Shells & Cheese
Growing up I used to eat boxed mac and cheese fairly often. Both the blue box and Velveeta.
When I first moved out, a 60 cent box of macaroni and cheese was a decent dinner for me.
My husband, however, who is known for his version of mac & cheese, hates boxed macaroni so I haven’t bought it in years.
Then I learned I could make this creamy macaroni recipe easily on the stovetop and the box became obsolete in our house.
This stovetop macaroni and cheese recipe comes together really quickly and tastes really good. It is creamy and cheesy, almost like the kind you can find at Panera, but I use cheddar because I like it better than American cheese. Real cheese is better than powdered cheese any day.
Equipment you’ll need
Ingredients for stove top mac and cheese
Below is a list of the ingredients you’ll need to gather to make this recipe. Scroll all the way down for the full recipe card.
- PASTA – I used whole wheat shells in this batch but rotini, bowtie, elbow, etc. will work. Pick a short pasta.
- BUTTER – Salted or unsalted, use your favorite.
- FLOUR – I’ve only tested with all-purpose white flour.
- MILK – I use 2% because that’s what I generally have on hand.
- SEASONINGS – Salt, pepper, and red pepper flakes.
- CHEESE – You’ll need two cups of shredded cheese. I highly recommend shredding your own for the best, creamiest, melty results. I used a blend of cheddar and colby jack in this batch. If you have pre-shredded cheese, it will definitely work as well.
How to make creamy macaroni and cheese on the stovetop
- In a large pot of salted water, cook your noodles to the desired level of doneness. Drain & set aside.
- In the same pot, melt the butter until bubbly then whisk in the flour, one tablespoon at a time, making sure to fully cook each addition. The mixture should be a pale yellow.
- While whisking, add in the milk, a little bit at a time until thick and creamy. Season with salt, pepper, and red pepper flakes (optional).
- Remove the pan from the heat and add in the shredded cheese, stirring until fully melted.
- Finally, pour in the cooked pasta and stir to fully coat with cheese.
- For added heat, add a squirt or two of Sriracha to the roux.
- Switch up the cheeses. I used cheddar but American would work nicely or try my pepper jack version.
- Take it one step further by pouring the prepared mac & cheese into a baking dish, sprinkling with seasoned panko bread crumbs, and baking until golden and bubbly.
- Sprinkle some crumbled bacon on top to make it extra special.
Tips & Suggestions
- Shred your own cheese! Packaged cheese had non-caking agents that prevent it from melting nicely. Shredding your own makes a difference, give it a try! (but pre-shredded cheese will work).
- I like shells & cheese because the cheese really gets into the noodle for little pools of cheese 😍 but other shapes work like elbows or bow ties.
- You can skip the red pepper flakes entirely if you don’t want any heat. Paprika would be a good replacement or even dried mustard.
What to serve with this Creamy Macaroni and Cheese Recipe
Need more macaroni and cheese recipes? Try these:
- Hard Rock Cafe Twisted Mac & Cheese
- Mac & Cheese in a Mug
- 3 Ingredient Slow Cooker Macaroni & Cheese
- Easy Baked Macaroni and Cheese
Click here for my entire collection of pasta recipes.
Connect with Persnickety Plates!
Follow along on my social media so you never miss a post!
Also, sign up to receive an email in your inbox for each new recipe: